Like a janissary, Ortaylı stands his ground
Güncelleme Tarihi:
In the scheme of daily life in Turkey, amid pressing problems abroad and a national tragedy and crime still unsolved near the city of Mardin, the routines of a museum may well seem insignificant. But we think in this case a minor skirmish at Istanbul’s Topkapı Palace is worth noting. For a large principle is at stake.
The hero in this case is İlber Ortaylı, the chairman of the venerable palace-turned museum. Ortaylı is generally known for two things: first, his esteem as historian and author; second, the fact that he speaks his mind. Ortaylı, in fact, is incapable of NOT sharing his opinion, and his opinions are always strong.
So it was entirely in character this week when Ortayli moved to correct any possible historic errors that could be made under the notion to have automated holographic “janissaries,” the legendary palace guards of the Ottomans, parading for tourists wandering in the facility’s inner chambers.
At first glance, this idea being promoted by the Ministry of Tourism and Culture would seem to have its appeal. Billed as a “first” in a museum, the idea would share this important dimension of Ottoman history, including period dress and symbolism, with the thousands of tourists visiting each year.
Let’s first set aside this “first” argument for roving holograms. The idea has been implemented in at least one French museum, and it is a notion afoot in museum circles and in other sectors catering to tourists worldwide and does not qualify as original. So that argument is out.
But the serious objection is that the proposal, still under discussion, envisions having the janissaries roam in what was the weapons section, a part of the museum undergoing restoration. The room in question is said to be some 20 meters large.
Ortaylı’s objection is that the sultans of yesteryear never allowed janissaries inside the main palace. The soldiers were never allowed to cross what is known as the second atrium.
There may well be other places to try out the hologram technology. There may well be other figures from history that could be allowed to enter the palace virtually. But the fastidiousness with which the museum chief has insisted on historical accuracy is admirable. Too many of Turkey’s treasures have been tainted by short-term commercial objectives. One of the greatest palaces in the world should not be among them.
The janissaries were famous for being tough, uncompromising, occasionally a little capricious and always ready to stand their ground. If these were the necessary characteristics, Ortaylı might not have made a bad janissary himself. We are confident he will stand his ground, as well he should.